Hedging, Virtual Hedging, FIFO Compliance
Many strategies, such as grid traders or systems with multiple algorithms, often
hold opposite positions of the same asset. This would normally violate the
NFA and FIFO compliance
required by international brokers and cause rejection of orders. Even if orders
are accepted, holding long and short positions simultaneously increases risk, margin,
and trading costs. It is always preferable to close an open position, rather than
opening a new position in opposite direction.
take care of NFA and FIFO compliant trading, i.e. close first opened positions first,
and avoid concurrent long and short positions. This can require lengthy and awkward
coding when several algorithms trade with the same assets. The
virtual hedging mechanism
of Zorro S guarantees FIFO compliant closing of trades and prevents positions in
opposite directions, even with complex portfolio systems. This happens in a completely
transparent way; the script needs no special code and can arbitrarily open and close
The virtual hedging mechanism uses two layers of trades,
phantom trades and pool trades. The pool trades
hold the net amount of the phantom trades. The strategy script only handles the
phantom trades, while the broker only receives orders for the pool trades. Pool
trades are opened or closed when phantom trades open or close, but not necessarily
in that order. Phantom trades can be open in both directions at the same time, but
the resulting pool trades are only open in one direction per asset, either short
Systems with virtual hedging are almost always* superior to
'real hedging' systems that hold opposite positions. Aside from NFA and FIFO compliance, virtual
hedging systems achieve higher profit due to reduced transaction costs, need less
capital due to lower margin requirements, and have lower risk because trades are
closed earlier and less exposed to the market. Some brokers, such as
Oanda, apply virtual hedging automatically to all trades.
For brokers that don't, Zorro can activate virtual hedging with the Hedge
variable (see below). All trades are then entered in phantom
mode. When the net amount - the difference of long and short open lots - changes,
Zorro automatically opens or closes pool trades in a way that FIFO order is observed
and market exposure is minimized.
Example: several long positions are open with a total amount of 100 lots. Now
a short trade of 40 lots is entered. The net amount is now 60 lots (100 long lots
minus 40 short lots). Zorro closes the oldest long pool trades fully or partially
until the sum of open positions is at 60 lots. If partial closing is not supported,
the oldest long pool trades are fully closed until the remaining position is at
or below 60 lots. If it's less than 60 lots, a new long pool trade is opened at
the difference. In both cases the net amount ends up at exactly 60 lots.
Virtual hedging affects performance parameters.
The equity curves of a system with or without virtual hedging are
rather similar, but the number of trades, the profit factor, the win rate, and the
average trade duration can be very different. Here's an example of the same grid trading
system without and with virtual hedging:
EUR/CHF grid trader, real hedging, 402 trades, avg duration
14 weeks, win rate 95%, profit factor
10, total profit $15900
EUR/CHF grid trader, virtual hedging, 261 trades, avg duration
2 weeks, win rate 65%, profit factor 3,
total profit $16300
* Only exception: Systems that exploit rollover / swap arbitrage must hold 'real'
Hedging behavior; determines how simultaneous long and short positions with the
same asset are handled.
||No hedging; automatically closes opposite positions with the same
asset when a new position is opened (NFA compliant;
default for NFA accounts).
||Hedging across algos; automatically closes opposite positions with the
same algo when a new position is opened (not NFA
compliant in multi-algo systems; default for non-NFA accounts).
||Full hedging; long and short positions even with the same
algo can be open at the same time (not NFA compliant).
||Virtual hedging without partial closing. Long and short positions
can be open simultaneously, but only the net position is open in the
broker account. Phantom trades immediately trigger the opening or
closing of corresponding pool positions. NFA and FIFO compliant.
Zorro S required.
||Virtual hedging with partial closing and pooling. Phantom trades in
the run function are collected and result in a
single pool trade. Intrabar phantom trades trigger pool trades
pool positions are partially closed to match the net amount. NFA and
FIFO compliant. Zorro S required.
- Virtual hedging is used in [Test] and [Trade]
mode only. The performance report and the
Total statistics reflect the pool trades, the
Long/Short statistics reflect the phantom trades.
Only exception is NumPendingTotal, which is the number of pending
phantom trades (pool trades are never pending).
- 'Real' phantom trades for the purpose of "equity curve trading" also contribute to the Long/Short statistics,
but won't trigger pool trades.
- Hedge = 5 is preferable to Hedge = 4 since
it opens fewer trades and thus causes less transaction costs. Hedge
= 4 is required when partial closing is not supported by the
broker or account. This is often not documented, but you can find out with the
TradeTest script. Start a session,
set Lots to 10, open a position, then set Lots to 5 and close the position.
If this fails, your account does not support partial closing.
- Hedge >= 2 enables full hedging and won't automatically close opposite positions. If this is required, do it by
- The number of open net lots of pool and phantom trades can be evaluated
with the LotsPool and LotsPhantom
variables. They can get temporarily out of sync when pool trades are externally
or manually closed. In that case the difference remains until the next phantom
trade with the same asset synchronizes the variables again.
- Opening pool trades can be prevented by setting Lots
= 0. As long as no phantom trades are
opened or closed, pool trades won't then be opened even when
LotsPool and LotsPhantom
- Pool trades have no profit target and no TMF, but
- for protection against large price shocks - a very distant stop loss at about
25% difference to the current price. They are normally only controlled by opening
and closing phantom trades. However they appear in trade enumeration loops and
can be identified by TradeIsPool.
- Pool trades that were rejected by the broker will be re-entered at every
bar until LotsPool and LotsPhantom
are in sync again.
- Dependent on open trades, closing a phantom trade can cause closing of several
pool trades and/or opening of a new pool trade, especially in Hedge
= 4 mode. A phantom trade can close with a loss and the subsequent
pool trade with a win, or vice versa. This is a perfectly normal consequence
of virtual hedging and not a bug.
- In virtual hedging mode, the result window displays
only open pool trades and pending phantom trades. When algo
identifiers are used, pool trades are displayed either with the identifier
of the triggering trade, or with a "NET" identifier.
- Hedging is prohibited for US based accounts due to NFA Compliance Rule 2-43(b).
Such accounts normally require the NFA
flag and either virtual or no hedging. The NFA flag does not
affect phantom trades, which can be simultaneously open in both directions.
Hedge = 5; // virtual hedging in trade mode
Hedge = 2; // full hedging in test mode
LotsPool, Phantom trades
latest version online